Duplicate code is one of the most pungent code smells. A rule that is often used is to re-structure code once it is duplicated in three or more places.
Common duplication problems, and corresponding solutions are:
Complex classes like TreeGen often do a lot of different things. To break such a class down, we need to identify a cohesive component within that class. A common approach to find such a component is to look for fields/methods that share the same prefixes, or suffixes. You can also have a look at the cohesion graph to spot any un-connected, or weakly-connected components.
Once you have determined the fields that belong together, you can apply the Extract Class refactoring. If the component makes sense as a sub-class, Extract Subclass is also a candidate, and is often faster.
While breaking up the class, it is a good idea to analyze how other classes use TreeGen, and based on these observations, apply Extract Interface, too.
| 1 | <?php |
||
| 12 | class TreeGen implements TreeGenerable |
||
| 13 | { |
||
| 14 | protected $groupBy; |
||
| 15 | protected $tree; |
||
| 16 | public $championship; |
||
| 17 | public $settings; |
||
| 18 | protected $numFighters; |
||
| 19 | |||
| 20 | /** |
||
| 21 | * @param Championship $championship |
||
| 22 | * @param $groupBy |
||
| 23 | */ |
||
| 24 | public function __construct(Championship $championship, $groupBy) |
||
| 31 | |||
| 32 | /** |
||
| 33 | * Generate tree groups for a championship. |
||
| 34 | * |
||
| 35 | * @throws TreeGenerationException |
||
| 36 | */ |
||
| 37 | public function run() |
||
| 47 | |||
| 48 | /** |
||
| 49 | * Get the biggest entity group |
||
| 50 | * @param $userGroups |
||
| 51 | * |
||
| 52 | * @return int |
||
| 53 | */ |
||
| 54 | private function getMaxFightersByEntity($userGroups): int |
||
| 64 | |||
| 65 | /** |
||
| 66 | * Get Competitor's list ordered by entities |
||
| 67 | * Countries for Internation Tournament, State for a National Tournament, etc. |
||
| 68 | * |
||
| 69 | * @return Collection |
||
| 70 | */ |
||
| 71 | private function getFightersByEntity($fighters): Collection |
||
| 84 | |||
| 85 | /** |
||
| 86 | * Get the size the first round will have |
||
| 87 | * @param $fighterCount |
||
| 88 | * @return int |
||
| 89 | */ |
||
| 90 | protected function getTreeSize($fighterCount, $groupSize) |
||
| 104 | |||
| 105 | /** |
||
| 106 | * Repart BYE in the tree, |
||
| 107 | * @param $fighterGroups |
||
| 108 | * @param int $max |
||
| 109 | * |
||
| 110 | * @return Collection |
||
| 111 | */ |
||
| 112 | private function repart($fighterGroups, $max) |
||
| 126 | |||
| 127 | /** |
||
| 128 | * Insert byes in an homogen way. |
||
| 129 | * |
||
| 130 | * @param Collection $fighters |
||
| 131 | * @param Collection $byeGroup |
||
| 132 | * |
||
| 133 | * @return Collection |
||
| 134 | */ |
||
| 135 | private function insertByes(Collection $fighters, Collection $byeGroup) |
||
| 160 | |||
| 161 | /** |
||
| 162 | * @param Collection $usersByArea |
||
| 163 | * @param integer $area |
||
| 164 | * @param integer $round |
||
| 165 | * @param integer $shuffle |
||
| 166 | * |
||
| 167 | */ |
||
| 168 | public function generateGroupsForRound($usersByArea, $area, $round, $shuffle) |
||
| 186 | |||
| 187 | /** |
||
| 188 | * @param $area |
||
| 189 | * @param $order |
||
| 190 | * @param $round |
||
| 191 | * @param $parent |
||
| 192 | * @return FightersGroup |
||
| 193 | */ |
||
| 194 | protected function saveGroup($area, $order, $round, $parent): FightersGroup |
||
| 207 | |||
| 208 | |||
| 209 | /** |
||
| 210 | * @param integer $groupSize |
||
| 211 | * @return Collection |
||
| 212 | */ |
||
| 213 | View Code Duplication | public function createByeGroup($groupSize): Collection |
|
| 222 | |||
| 223 | /** |
||
| 224 | * @param $fighters |
||
| 225 | * @param Collection $fighterGroups |
||
| 226 | * @return Collection |
||
| 227 | */ |
||
| 228 | public function adjustFightersGroupWithByes($fighters, $fighterGroups): Collection |
||
| 243 | |||
| 244 | /** |
||
| 245 | * Get All Groups on previous round |
||
| 246 | * @param $currentRound |
||
| 247 | * @return Collection |
||
| 248 | */ |
||
| 249 | private function getPreviousRound($currentRound) |
||
| 254 | |||
| 255 | /** |
||
| 256 | * Get the next group on the right ( parent ), final round being the ancestor |
||
| 257 | * @param $matchNumber |
||
| 258 | * @param Collection $previousRound |
||
| 259 | * @return mixed |
||
| 260 | */ |
||
| 261 | private function getParentGroup($matchNumber, $previousRound) |
||
| 267 | |||
| 268 | /** |
||
| 269 | * Save Groups with their parent info |
||
| 270 | * @param integer $numRounds |
||
| 271 | * @param $numFightersEliminatory |
||
| 272 | */ |
||
| 273 | protected function pushGroups($numRounds, $numFightersEliminatory) |
||
| 284 | |||
| 285 | /** |
||
| 286 | * Group Fighters by area |
||
| 287 | * @return Collection |
||
| 288 | * @throws TreeGenerationException |
||
| 289 | */ |
||
| 290 | private function getFightersByArea() |
||
| 308 | |||
| 309 | /** |
||
| 310 | * Attach a parent to every child for nestedSet Navigation |
||
| 311 | */ |
||
| 312 | private function addParentToChildren($numFightersEliminatory) |
||
| 332 | |||
| 333 | /** |
||
| 334 | * Create Bye Groups to adjust tree |
||
| 335 | * @param $byeCount |
||
| 336 | * @return Collection |
||
| 337 | */ |
||
| 338 | View Code Duplication | protected function createNullsGroup($byeCount): Collection |
|
| 347 | } |
||
| 348 |
Let’s take a look at an example:
In the above example, the authenticate() method works fine as long as you just pass instances of MyUser. However, if you now also want to pass a different sub-classes of User which does not have a getDisplayName() method, the code will break.
Available Fixes
Change the type-hint for the parameter:
Add an additional type-check:
Add the method to the parent class: